R

Why do traders lose money? Nearly nine in ten accounts share one number

Why do traders lose money? SEBI and ESMA counted: 74% to 93% of retail accounts lose. Here is the one number they share, and how to read yours.

Why do traders lose money? Regulators have stopped guessing and started counting. In India, SEBI found that 87.7% of individual traders in equity derivatives made a net loss in FY26. In the EU, ESMA wrote in 2018 that 74% to 89% of retail CFD accounts typically lose money.

Here is the short definition. A trader loses money when the average result per trade, after costs, is below zero, and keeps trading anyway. It is rarely one bad trade. It is a negative expectancy repeated hundreds of times, with leverage and fees on top. The good news is that this number sits in your own history, and you can see it.

Why do traders lose money, according to the regulators?

Start with the counts, because they are not opinions. SEBI's September 2024 study covered more than one crore (ten million) individual traders in Indian equity futures and options between FY22 and FY24. 93% of them lost money. Their aggregate losses exceeded ₹1.8 lakh crore over the three years, and loss-makers lost about ₹2 lakh each on average, transaction costs included.

SEBI repeated the exercise in August 2026 for FY25 and FY26. The picture improved slightly and stayed grim. The share of loss-makers fell from 90.9% in FY25 to 87.7% in FY26. Aggregate net losses fell about 18%, to ₹91,685 crore. Options alone produced 92% of those losses.

Share of retail traders or accounts that lost money

SEBI, F&O, FY22–FY2493%SEBI, F&O, FY2590.9%SEBI, F&O, FY2687.7%ESMA, CFD, upper range89%ESMA, CFD, lower range74%

Source: SEBI study FY22–FY24 (Sept 2024); SEBI study FY25–FY26 (Aug 2026); ESMA press release (27 Mar 2018)

Two different regulators, two different products, two different continents. The range is 74% to 93%. That is not a market that happened to be difficult one year. It is a structure.

The age data adds a detail. In FY26, traders under 30 made up 43% of individual derivatives traders, up from 31% in FY22, and 89% of them were loss-makers. The newest cohort loses at least as often as the rest.

Is it the market, the costs, or the trader?

All three, and they stack. SEBI estimates that individuals paid about ₹25,000 crore in transaction costs in each of FY25 and FY26. Cumulative costs from FY22 to FY26 were about ₹1 lakh crore, with brokerage close to half of it. Securities transaction tax paid by individuals rose 35% in a year, from ₹4,920 crore to ₹6,645 crore.

Costs matter because they are certain. A trade can win or lose. The fee is paid on both. A strategy that is flat before costs is a losing strategy after them, and the more you trade, the more the cost line dominates your result.

But costs do not explain everything. SEBI reports that gross trading losses of individuals, before costs, were still about ₹72,000 crore in FY26. The trades themselves lost. That is the part a journal can read.

Why do forex traders lose money?

Retail forex and CFD trading has its own accelerator: leverage. ESMA's 2018 measures capped retail leverage at 30:1 on major currency pairs, 20:1 on non-major pairs, gold and major indices, 10:1 on other commodities, 5:1 on individual equities and 2:1 on cryptocurrencies. It also imposed a margin close-out at 50% of required margin and negative balance protection per account.

Read those rules as a description of the problem. A regulator does not standardise a close-out rule unless accounts were being wiped out faster than their owners could react. At 30:1, a 1% move against a fully margined position is 30% of the margin committed. Leverage does not change your expectancy. It changes how fast a negative one reaches zero.

The same measures introduced a standardised risk warning that states the provider's own percentage of losing retail accounts. You can read that figure on an EU CFD broker's website before you open an account.

Does trading more make it better or worse?

Worse, in the data. Barber and Odean studied 66,465 households at a US discount broker from 1991 to 1996. The average household turned over about 75% of its portfolio a year and earned 16.4% net. The households that traded the most earned 11.4% net, while the market returned 17.9%. More activity, lower return. The authors attribute the gap largely to trading costs and overconfidence.

The mechanism is simple. Each extra trade adds a fee and adds another draw from your distribution. If the average draw is negative, more draws add more loss. We covered this in detail in overtrading: the loss is in the count, not in any single trade.

Why do losing traders hold their losers?

Because losses hurt more than gains please. In Tversky and Kahneman's 1992 estimates, a loss weighed about 2.25 times as much as a gain of the same size. That asymmetry has a visible consequence in trading accounts.

Odean's 1998 study of discount-brokerage accounts from 1987 to 1993 found that investors sold winning positions much more readily than losing ones, and that the losers they kept did not go on to justify the choice. This is the disposition effect: you close the winner early to lock in the feeling, and you let the loser run to avoid making it real.

Put the two habits together and you get the classic losing profile. Small wins, large losses, and a win rate that looks healthy.

What is the signature of a losing account?

It is not a low win rate. It is an average loss larger than the average win, by more than the win rate can cover. SEBI's own FY26 figures show the shape at the population level: the average loss per loss-maker was ₹1.47 lakh, while the average profit per profit-maker was ₹1.22 lakh, about 21% smaller.

The formula that captures it is trading expectancy: win rate times average win, minus loss rate times average loss, measured in R. A trader who wins 58% of the time with an average win of 0.90R and an average loss of -1.45R has an expectancy of -0.09R per trade. That trader feels right more often than wrong, and still loses.

87.7%

Individual F&O traders with a net loss, FY26

SEBI, Aug 2026

92%

Share of those losses from options

SEBI, Aug 2026

₹1.47 lakh

Average loss per loss-maker, FY26

vs ₹1.22 lakh average profit

11.4%

Net annual return, most active households

vs 17.9% for the market, Barber & Odean 2000

Source: SEBI (Aug 2026); Barber & Odean, Journal of Finance (2000)

Regulators can count accounts. They cannot tell you which one is yours, or why. That needs your own trades.

What your journal would show

Here is a six-month history from one account, using illustrative demo data. 200 trades. Win rate 58%. Average win 0.90R. Average loss -1.45R. Expectancy -0.09R. The account owner described the period as "mostly green".

Cumulative result, 200 trades

Illustrative demo data

R2.1R-7.6R-17.4Month 1R2.1Month 2R1.4Month 3R-2.6Month 4R-6.8Month 5R-11.9Month 6R-17.4

Source: Socius Trades, illustrative demo data

The curve does not collapse on one day. It bends in month 3 and keeps bending. A trade-by-trade view shows why: the win rate never dropped below 55%, but the average loss widened from -1.10R to -1.70R as stops were moved. In the same demo data, losing trades closed after the original stop level averaged -2.30R.

This is what Socius Trades is built to show. It connects read-only to cTrader or MetaTrader 4/5, imports the trades you already executed and computes expectancy, R-multiples, drawdown and results by session, instrument, hour and day. You can ask Socius AI in plain language which instrument carries your losses, or what your expectancy is after a losing day. It never places, closes or modifies a trade, and never touches your funds. We look. We never touch.

What can you actually do about it?

There is no rule that turns a negative expectancy positive by itself. There are rules that make the number visible and stop it from compounding.

  1. Measure in R, not in money. Fix your risk per trade before entry, then record every result as a multiple of it. Without R, your average win and average loss cannot be compared.
  2. Compute your expectancy on at least 50 trades. Win rate times average win, minus loss rate times average loss. If it is below zero, the next step is not more trades.
  3. Count your costs per trade. Spread, commission, swap, taxes. SEBI's ₹25,000 crore a year is the aggregate of many small lines. Find yours.
  4. Compare your average loss with your planned loss. If your average loss is -1.45R on trades planned at -1R, the gap is the stop you moved. That is a behaviour, not a market condition.
  5. Size down after losses, not up. The position sizing formula works only if the risk you enter is the risk you planned.
  6. Set a trade-count ceiling per day. Barber and Odean's most active households paid for activity with return. A ceiling caps the number of draws from a negative distribution.

None of this promises a profit. It replaces a feeling with a number. Regulators found that roughly nine in ten retail derivatives traders lose. Your history can tell you whether you are in that group, and by how much per trade.

Trading involves risk of loss. Socius Trades is an analytics tool, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

Why do traders lose money?+

Most retail traders lose because their average result per trade, after costs, is below zero. SEBI found 87.7% of individual Indian equity derivatives traders lost money in FY26, and ESMA reported in 2018 that 74% to 89% of EU retail CFD accounts typically lose. Costs, leverage and small-wins-large-losses habits combine.

What percentage of traders lose money?+

It depends on the market and the period measured. SEBI counted 93% loss-makers among individual F&O traders over FY22 to FY24, 90.9% in FY25 and 87.7% in FY26. ESMA's 2018 product intervention cited 74% to 89% of retail CFD accounts typically losing money on their investments.

Why do forex traders lose money?+

Leverage speeds up a negative expectancy. ESMA capped retail leverage at 30:1 on major currency pairs in 2018 and imposed a margin close-out at 50% of required margin. At 30:1, a 1% adverse move equals 30% of the margin committed, so losses reach the account balance quickly.

Does trading more often help retail traders?+

The academic evidence says no. Barber and Odean studied 66,465 US households from 1991 to 1996. The most active traders earned 11.4% net a year while the market returned 17.9%. The average household earned 16.4%. The authors attributed the gap largely to trading costs and overconfidence.

Sources
  1. Profitability of Individual Traders in the Equity Derivatives Segment (FY25–FY26) — Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), August 2026
  2. Updated SEBI study reveals 93% of individual traders incurred losses in equity F&O between FY22 and FY24 — Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), 23 September 2024
  3. ESMA agrees to prohibit binary options and restrict CFDs to protect retail investors — European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), 27 March 2018
  4. Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth: The Common Stock Investment Performance of Individual Investors — Barber & Odean, The Journal of Finance (2000)
  5. Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses? (CFA Digest summary) — CFA Institute, summarising Odean, The Journal of Finance (1998)
  6. Advances in Prospect Theory: Cumulative Representation of Uncertainty — Tversky & Kahneman, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty (1992)

Trading involves risk of loss. Socius Trades is an analytics tool, not investment advice.

Written by

Socius News

The editorial desk of Socius Trades

Socius News is the editorial desk of Socius Trades. It reads the week ahead, revisits three centuries of market history, compares trading tools on the facts and explains the numbers behind a trader's results. Every article is sourced, dated and reviewed before publication. No signals, no forecasts, no promises.

Keep reading

More in The mirror

View all
See it on your own trades

Your broker history already knows the answer.

Connect an account in read-only mode and Socius Trades turns your executions into expectancy, R-multiples, drawdown and results by session. We look. We never touch.

Trading involves risk of loss. Socius Trades is an analytics tool, not investment advice.