VS

Socius Trades vs Myfxbook: the Myfxbook alternative built to be read, not shown

A Myfxbook alternative that reads your fills in private. Socius Trades vs Myfxbook: prices dated 29 October 2026, connections, verification, AutoTrade.

People searching for a Myfxbook alternative usually arrive from a public system page: a verified gain figure, a drawdown figure, a widget, and a comment thread under it. Here is the definition first. A Myfxbook alternative is a trading journal that imports your executed trades in read-only mode and computes expectancy, R-multiples and drawdown for you alone, without Myfxbook's public track-record pages, community and copy-trading layer. The question is not which tool shows more people your curve. It is which one shows you.

Socius Trades vs Myfxbook is a comparison between two tools that connect to the same broker account and point in opposite directions. Myfxbook points outward: it verifies your account so that others can trust it, publishes the curve, and lets other accounts copy it through AutoTrade. Socius Trades points inward: it imports your fills in read-only mode, computes the numbers, and lets Socius AI answer questions about your own history. Prices and plan details below are as listed on both official sites on 29 October 2026.

Socius Trades

Socius Trades

What did I do, and what does it say about me?

  • Read-only import from cTrader and MetaTrader 4/5
  • Expectancy, R-multiples, drawdown, sessions, hours, days
  • Socius AI on your own history, private by design
  • Free plan, Essential at 129.99 EUR a year, 14-day trial
VS
Myfxbook

Myfxbook

Verify it, publish it, let others copy it

  • Free, advertising-funded, no account limit in its own words
  • Verified track record and trading privileges, public system pages, widgets
  • Auto Update free every 2 to 4 hours; Live Update $60 a year per account
  • AutoTrade copy trading, terms to be confirmed on its help page
Same broker login, opposite audience. Myfxbook builds a track record for other people to read. Socius Trades builds a mirror that only you read.

What is Myfxbook built for?

Myfxbook describes itself as the first social community for forex traders. Its about page, read on 29 October 2026, lists the parts: automatic analysis of connected accounts, a private portfolio of several systems, a dashboard with market status, news and an economic calendar, a system search where the results are described as real and verified, following and discussion, and widgets you can embed on a blog or a forum. The sentence that explains the product is about sharing. Traders can share audited system pages with potential clients, and buyers can have a provider's results audited before paying.

Verification is the core. Myfxbook's help pages say that since performance can be manipulated with MetaTrader accounts, it built an automatic verification system. A system is not shown on the public systems page until both its track record and its trading privileges are verified. Track record verification connects to your broker several times a day with your investor password, which the help page calls a read-only password. Trading privileges verification asks you to prove the account is yours, by changing the investor password to an authorization key or by placing a pending order with that key as the comment. The FAQ is candid about the limit: it takes every possible measure, and verified accounts may still contain inaccuracies outside its control.

The analytics are real, and they are account-level. The help pages define drawdown as calculated on the closed P/L of the account, and expectancy as what you can expect to make, win or lose, on every trade. Standard deviation, z-score and time-weighted return are documented too. MetaTrader 4 accounts update every 5 minutes, FxTrade and FxGame accounts every 60 minutes, and a new account is analyzed in up to 2 minutes. Myfxbook also runs AutoTrade, its copy-trading service, where other accounts replicate a verified system. Its help page was not reachable on 29 October 2026, so its fees and system-selection rules are to be confirmed there.

What is Socius Trades built for?

Socius Trades does one thing: it reads. You connect your broker accounts in read-only mode, cTrader or MetaTrader 4/5 through MetaApi cloud or the Socius EA, and the platform imports your executed trades. From that history it computes expectancy, R-multiples, drawdown, and results by session, by instrument, by hour and by day of the week. Socius AI answers questions about that history in plain language: which session loses, what your size does after a loss, how often you close a winner early.

Two design choices define it. First, read-only. Socius Trades never places, closes or modifies a trade, and never touches funds. We look. We never touch. Second, your data stays yours. There is no public system page, no widget, no verified badge for a buyer, and no copy-trading layer. The analysis runs on your own executions and is meant for one reader.

Read-only sources Socius Trades imports from
  • cTradercTrader
  • MetaTrader 4MetaTrader 4
  • MetaTrader 5MetaTrader 5

Socius Trades also ships real-time charts, an economic calendar, a position calculator and a community hub, and all of them are secondary to the analytics. If you have read the best trading journal 2026 guide, the logic is the same. The platform is not trying to be an audience. It is trying to be the mirror.

Socius Trades vs Myfxbook: what is the difference?

MyfxbookSocius Trades
Core questionCan other people trust this curve, and can they copy it?What did I do, and what does it say about me?
Primary objectYour account's equity curve, verified and publishedYour executed trades, read from the broker
Broker connectionMetaTrader 4/5 via Auto Update (read-only credentials), EA Publisher or Live Update; other platforms listed on its help pagesRead-only import: cTrader, MetaTrader 4/5 via MetaApi cloud or the Socius EA
Update frequencyAuto Update every 2 to 4 hours; EA Publisher every 5 minutes while the platform is open; Live Update described as real-timeTo be confirmed on the FAQ page
Can it execute trades?AutoTrade copies a system's trades into a follower's account; terms to be confirmedNo, by design; it cannot place, close or modify a trade
AnalyticsGain, drawdown on closed P/L, expectancy, standard deviation, z-score, time-weighted returnExpectancy, R-multiples, drawdown, results by session, instrument, hour and day
AudiencePublic system pages, widgets, verified badges, communityYou, in private
AINone listed on the pages readSocius AI: ask your own history a question
AccountsNo limit, in its own wordsTo be confirmed on the pricing page
Free planThe service itself is free and advertising-fundedYes
TrialNot applicable14 days on Essential
PriceFree; Live Update $60 a year per account, one account at a timeEssential 129.99 EUR a year, Pro 279.99 EUR, Ultimate 499.99 EUR

Myfxbook is a trademark of its owner; Socius Trades is not affiliated with Myfxbook. cTrader and MetaTrader are trademarks of their owners; Socius Trades is not affiliated with either.

Is Myfxbook free, and what does Socius Trades cost?

Is Myfxbook free? Its FAQ answers in one line: no cost, the service is absolutely free, and it is funded by advertising. The same page says you can add as many accounts as you need. There is one paid item on the pages read on 29 October 2026. Live Update, the server-side method that keeps an account current while your terminal is closed, is billed yearly at $60. It covers one account at a time, can be moved to another account in your portfolio once every 24 hours, and needs a separate subscription for each account you want live at the same time. The two free methods remain: Auto Update, which uses your read-only credentials and refreshes every 2 to 4 hours depending on server load, and EA Publisher, which runs on Windows and posts every 5 minutes while the platform is open.

$0

Myfxbook core service

advertising-funded, no account limit, 29 October 2026

$60

Myfxbook Live Update, per year

one account at a time, one subscription per live account

129.99 EUR

Socius Trades Essential, per year

about 10.83 EUR a month, 14-day trial

0

Socius Trades Free plan

contents listed on the pricing page

Source: myfxbook.com FAQ and help pages, sociustrades.com/pricing, read on 29 October 2026

Socius Trades is annual only. Essential costs 129.99 EUR a year, about 10.83 EUR a month, with a 14-day trial. Pro is 279.99 EUR and Ultimate 499.99 EUR a year. A Free plan exists; its exact contents are listed on the pricing page and are not repeated here.

Annual price of each paid option, read on 29 October 2026

Myfxbook in USD, Socius Trades in EUR; shown side by side for scale only

Myfxbook core (USD)0Myfxbook Live Update (USD)60Socius Trades Essential (EUR)130.0Socius Trades Pro (EUR)280.0Socius Trades Ultimate (EUR)500.0

Source: myfxbook.com help, sociustrades.com/pricing, 29 October 2026

Price is the wrong place to stop. Free and 129.99 EUR are not two prices for the same thing. Myfxbook's free tier is funded by advertising and exists inside a marketplace where verified systems are shown to buyers and copied through AutoTrade. Socius Trades charges a subscription and shows your curve to nobody. The fair comparison is between what each tool is for, not between zero and 129.99.

Why does a Myfxbook alternative that only reads still find your mistakes?

Because the mistakes are in the fills, not in the gain figure. Terrance Odean's 1998 study of 10,000 discount-brokerage accounts from 1987 to 1993 found that investors realized 14.8 percent of their paper gains against 9.8 percent of their paper losses, a ratio of about 1.5. The winners they sold went on to beat the losers they kept by 3.4 percentage points over the following year. A monthly gain percentage does not show that. A list of closed trades, read one by one, does.

Brad Barber and Odean's 2000 study of 66,465 households from 1991 to 1996 measured the cost of activity itself. The average household turned over 75 percent of its portfolio a year. The households that traded most earned 11.4 percent a year against 17.9 percent for the market. Turnover is a count, and a count is invisible on an equity curve that only tells you where you ended.

Here is the structural point. Myfxbook's unit is the account: gain, drawdown on closed P/L, a verified curve that a stranger can trust. That is the right unit for an audience. Your own unit is the trade. One R-multiple per fill, so that a 0.8R winner and a -2.6R loser stop hiding inside the same monthly percentage. Trading expectancy computed in R, split by session and by hour, is what tells you where the curve came from. Myfxbook does publish an expectancy figure, and it is account-level. The split is what a private mirror adds.

“A verified curve tells a stranger what happened to your account. Your fills tell you what you did to it. A journal that only reads the second one does not need an audience to find the pattern.”
— Socius News

None of this makes Myfxbook's approach wrong. A verified, public track record solves a real problem, which is trust between a system provider and a buyer, and the research above was not written about Myfxbook users. It means that the behaviours the research measures, cutting winners, overtrading, sizing up after a loss, sit below the resolution of a public curve. A read-only journal starts there.

What your journal would show

Take a demo account on illustrative demo data: 180 trades over ten weeks on MetaTrader 5, imported read-only into Socius Trades. The account is up 6.1 percent, which is the number a public page would show. Expectancy is 0.09R across the whole sample. Split by session, London runs at 0.24R and the Asian session at -0.27R. Split by the previous trade's result, the trade that follows a loss is sized 1.4 times larger than the average and runs at -0.21R. Winners are closed at a median of 0.8R against a planned 2R. Maximum drawdown is 9.4 percent, and 6.8 of those points were made in the Asian session.

You can see all of that without publishing anything. Socius AI would answer "what do I do after a loss?" with the sizing figure and the R that follows it. On a public system page, the same ten weeks appear as one line: up 6.1 percent, drawdown 9.4 percent, verified. Both are true. One of them tells you which session to stop trading.

If that is the question you have after the session, the read-only route is on the Socius Trades pricing page: a Free plan, and a 14-day trial on Essential at 129.99 EUR a year. If your question is how to prove a curve to someone else, Myfxbook is built for that, free and advertising-funded on 29 October 2026, with Live Update at $60 a year per account.

Trading involves risk of loss. Socius Trades is an analytics tool, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Myfxbook alternative?+

A Myfxbook alternative is a trading journal that imports your executed trades in read-only mode and computes expectancy, R-multiples and drawdown for you alone, without public track-record pages, community or copy trading. Socius Trades is one: a read-only journal for cTrader and MetaTrader 4/5, with a Free plan and Essential at 129.99 euros a year with a 14-day trial.

Is Myfxbook free?+

Yes. Its FAQ, read on 29 October 2026, says the service is absolutely free and funded by advertising, with no limit on the number of accounts. One paid option exists: Live Update, a server-side real-time connection billed at 60 US dollars a year, covering one account at a time with a separate subscription per live account.

How does Myfxbook connect to MetaTrader 5?+

Its help page lists three methods on 29 October 2026. Auto Update is free, uses your read-only credentials and refreshes every 2 to 4 hours depending on server load. EA Publisher is free, runs on Windows and posts every 5 minutes while the platform is open. Live Update is paid and described as real-time.

Socius Trades vs Myfxbook: which one executes trades?+

Socius Trades never does. It is read-only by design and cannot place, close or modify a trade or touch funds. Myfxbook runs AutoTrade, a copy-trading service in which follower accounts replicate a verified system's trades; its fees and selection rules were not reachable on 29 October 2026 and are to be confirmed on its help page.

Does Myfxbook calculate expectancy?+

Yes. Its help pages define expectancy as what you can expect to make, win or lose, on every trade, and drawdown as calculated on the closed P/L of the account, alongside standard deviation, z-score and time-weighted return. These are account-level figures. Socius Trades computes expectancy in R and splits it by session, instrument, hour and day.

Sources
  1. Myfxbook FAQ (read 29 October 2026) — Myfxbook
  2. Myfxbook Help: connection, verification and statistics (read 29 October 2026) — Myfxbook
  3. MetaTrader 5 connection methods (read 29 October 2026) — Myfxbook Help Center
  4. Live Update (read 29 October 2026) — Myfxbook Help Center
  5. About Myfxbook (read 29 October 2026) — Myfxbook
  6. Socius Trades pricing — Socius Trades
  7. Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses? (Journal of Finance, 1998) — Terrance Odean, UC Berkeley Haas
  8. Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth: The Common Stock Investment Performance of Individual Investors (Journal of Finance, 2000), abstract — Brad M. Barber and Terrance Odean, via IDEAS/RePEc

Trading involves risk of loss. Socius Trades is an analytics tool, not investment advice.

Written by

Socius News

The editorial desk of Socius Trades

Socius News is the editorial desk of Socius Trades. It reads the week ahead, revisits three centuries of market history, compares trading tools on the facts and explains the numbers behind a trader's results. Every article is sourced, dated and reviewed before publication. No signals, no forecasts, no promises.

Keep reading

More in Comparisons

View all
See it on your own trades

Your broker history already knows the answer.

Connect an account in read-only mode and Socius Trades turns your executions into expectancy, R-multiples, drawdown and results by session. We look. We never touch.

Trading involves risk of loss. Socius Trades is an analytics tool, not investment advice.